It's a scenario right out of the movies! There's a mid-term vacancy in the United States Senate. The Governor of the state in which the vacancy has occurred is responsible, at least constitutionally, to appoint a replacement till the next popular election. While all the special interests line up behind their candidates, the Governor selects a youth leader with no political experience to fill the post. It's an amazing story. The media elites hated it in 1939 when the Frank Capra film was released, as did the politicians. But, the American public loved it enough to make it among the highest grossing films of a film rich year. If you want to weigh the competition in 1939, go here. You see, the public votes with their feet and pocket book.
The allure of this fantasy isn't so mysterious. Even in 1939 Americans were skeptical, many cynical, about government. Special interests and party machines dominated the hallways of congress and the United States Senate was viewed as an exclusive club of up-and-in movers with custom crafted keys to the executive toilet. Of course, the Capra film perhaps exaggerated the graft and covered the political mess with a thin veneer of comic relief, an effort to soften the critical message underneath the plot. That the essential truth registered with the public in those confusing times seems to underscore the cynicism with which the public views established government.
So, fast-forward to 2012 for a similar setting. Senator Jim DeMint (R-SC) has resigned from the United States Senate to assume leadership of the Heritage Foundation in the New Year. Who can blame Him? Beating your head against the wall day after day in the Senate must come with a unique set of frustrations. Nevertheless, Governor Nikki Haley must now select someone to fill the Senate vacancy for two years, until the next election.
So, line up the special interests, haul out the usual suspects, and lets review the list of Republicans worthy of such an appointment. Let's not. First, if they're not serving somewhere at the time, it's probably because they got defeated in a race. Putting someone overlooked by the electorate into that spot may be thumbing your nose at the voters of SC. Second, the Republican establishment isn't all that attractive these days, having blown the 2012 election through fence-straddling and mask-wearing hypocrisy. Appointing another good old boy will just further alienate voters.
So, let's send Mr. Smith to Washington. There's been a grass-roots movement to impress our governor with the credentials of Bob Menges as a bona-fide candidate for this senatorial position. I'm for it. Here's why. One, Bob is passionate about the United States and government in general. He understands the United States Constitution better than most constitutional lawyers and has studied governement at a very deep level for many years. Two, Governor Haley has committed to appoint someone with strong conservative values. Bob Menges is solidly conservative at every point of political examination. He does not go with the flow or reflect the mood of the people around him. Third, having never served elective office, he is not indebted to political machines or office-holders. This would be odd in government today, a politician with no special interests other than to represent the people of his constitutency and the tenets of his conscience. Fourth, he is man of character. Nothing greater can be said of any human, that their character stands for something important.
So, the Governor will appoint someone to occupy the United States Senate seat held by Senator Jim DeMint. I'm standing with Bob Menges.
It's an appointment that makes a lot of sense.